Manatee County Holds Off on New Short-Term Rental Rules

Manatee County commissioners met to weigh how to regulate short-term rentals across the unincorporated county and decided against adopting anything new. Instead, they directed staff to keep researching options and report back, which means hosts operating outside the county's incorporated cities face no new registration, inspection or licensing requirements for now.
That is the practical news here: nothing changes on the ground yet. But the fact that commissioners are revisiting the issue at all signals pressure is building, and operators in the area should expect a more concrete proposal within the next several months rather than years.
Why the county's options are narrow
Florida law ties local governments' hands tightly on vacation rentals. Under the state's preemption statute, Florida Statute 509.032, counties and cities cannot ban short-term rentals outright, cannot cap how often a property is rented, and cannot limit how long a stay lasts. The only governments with broader authority are those that had rental ordinances on the books before June 1, 2011, which are grandfathered and can keep stricter local rules.
That cutoff matters for Manatee County specifically. The barrier-island cities within the county's borders, including Anna Maria, Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach, adopted rental licensing and inspection rules years before the state cutoff and have kept them: local permits, occupancy caps, parking requirements and code enforcement that can pull a rental license over repeat violations. The county commission's own authority covers only the unincorporated areas outside those cities, and without a pre-2011 ordinance of its own, it is limited to the narrower toolkit the state allows everyone else: registration, basic safety inspections and a requirement for a local contact person who can respond to complaints.
Florida's legislature has tried several times since 2023 to pass a statewide short-term rental registry that would have standardized these rules across every county. Each attempt has stalled, largely over disputes between home-rule advocates and lodging and real estate interests. Until Tallahassee settles that fight, counties like Manatee are left drafting whatever version of registration and enforcement the current preemption law permits, which is exactly the exercise commissioners have now kicked back to staff.
What hosts in the unincorporated county should track
The immediate obligation for hosts has not changed. Properties in unincorporated Manatee County are not yet required to register with the county, carry a county-issued permit or submit to a county safety inspection beyond whatever already applies under general building and fire code. That could shift once staff returns with a formal proposal, and the likely shape of that proposal, based on what other Florida counties without grandfathered ordinances have adopted, is a registration fee, a requirement to post a permit number in listings, and fines for hosts who fail to register or who generate repeat nuisance complaints.
Operators managing properties on Anna Maria Island or in Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach are in a different position already. Those cities' pre-2011 rules remain in force regardless of what the county decides, including occupancy limits tied to bedroom count and parking capacity, and licensing that must be renewed. Nothing from the county's current review changes those city-level requirements.
Where this fits against other Florida counties
Manatee is working through roughly the same questions that Walton County and Osceola County have already settled through local registries requiring a permit number and a 24-hour local contact on file, paired with escalating fines for violations rather than outright bans. Sarasota County, just south of Manatee, has also layered registration and inspection requirements onto unincorporated rentals in recent years while leaving its own barrier-island cities to their stricter grandfathered rules, a structure very similar to what Manatee appears headed toward.
What makes this round worth watching is timing. Complaints about short-term rentals in fast-growing unincorporated pockets of the county, driven by demand near the Anna Maria Island bridges and along the Manatee River corridor, have been building for several years without a formal registration system to track who is operating or where. A proposal with teeth, meaning fines large enough to change host behavior rather than a token fee, would mark a real shift from the status quo of largely self-policed listings.
For now, hosts and property managers in the unincorporated county have no paperwork to file and no deadline to meet. The practical move is to watch the commission's next meeting calendar for when staff returns with a drafted ordinance, since that is the point real compliance costs, whatever they turn out to be, will start to take shape.
Newsletter


